| Position | 1st Backup  | 2nd Backup | 3rd Backup | Fill Order |
| C | None | None | None | 1 |
| 1B | Aaron Judge | Jeff Bagwell | None | 8 |
| 2B | Aaron Judge | Jeff Bagwell | None | 3 |
| 3B | Aaron Judge | Jeff Bagwell | None | 4 |
| SS | Aaron Judge | Jeff Bagwell | None | 2 |
| LF | Aaron Judge | Jeff Bagwell | None | 7 |
| CF | Aaron Judge | Jeff Bagwell | None | 5 |
| RF | Aaron Judge | Jeff Bagwell | None | 6 |
|
