 |
View Old Forum Thread
yankeejim2323
I need cps
July 14, 2013 at 11:45PM View BBCode
I am willing to offer great draft picks in exchanged for CPs. Let me know if you have some available and are willing to trade them
shieldagent
July 15, 2013 at 02:27AM View BBCode
coach point trading is it fair for the other teams working within their 20 points ? i have some doubts.
yankeejim2323
July 15, 2013 at 03:04AM View formatted
You are viewing the raw post code; this allows you to copy a message with BBCode formatting intact.
It's been a debate here in the MCL for a long time about CP trading. Unfortunately we had one owner leave because he disagreed with it. It is something we have always done , guess it kinda got grandfathered into acceptance right, wrong, or indifferent.
moustique
is it fair ? my answer is, i don't believe so
is it against the rules ? the answer is no
My only advice for you is if you have a problem with that all you have to do is turn down every offer with CP trading in it
Some leagues have players who trade cp's all the time, and some leagues (even dynasty ones) all the players agree among themselves to not use this strategy. The Johnny Bench league for example didn't see a single cp trade in 46 seasons. Only once it was attempted and we as a league forced a reversal on it.
So far this league is the only one i'm in who allow to trade cp's, To be honest i'm curious to see the consequences good or bad on the teams involved.
I hope you had fun in your first season with us, I wish to see you stick around and rebuild the SF team.
July 15, 2013 at 05:53AM View BBCode
Dear Shieldagentis it fair ? my answer is, i don't believe so
is it against the rules ? the answer is no
My only advice for you is if you have a problem with that all you have to do is turn down every offer with CP trading in it
Some leagues have players who trade cp's all the time, and some leagues (even dynasty ones) all the players agree among themselves to not use this strategy. The Johnny Bench league for example didn't see a single cp trade in 46 seasons. Only once it was attempted and we as a league forced a reversal on it.
So far this league is the only one i'm in who allow to trade cp's, To be honest i'm curious to see the consequences good or bad on the teams involved.
I hope you had fun in your first season with us, I wish to see you stick around and rebuild the SF team.
yankeejim2323
Plus, it isn't a disadvantage. I believe when it's my turn to buy cps I pay a handsome rate for them. And when it cycles to where I sell those cps I get very valuable veterans to compliment my team. I thinks it's an effective tool to buy and sell an asset. And yes I understand the argument that real teams don't sell off their coaching and an opposing team doesn't train another teams players. But in real life every organization isn't made to limit the amount of players that can grow every year they try to nurture everyone equally.
Again, it is the most ideal situation? No. Can I understand the other side of the argument? Yes.
July 16, 2013 at 09:02AM View BBCode
It has always worked well for us. I think the strategy has helped many teams rebuild on a faster pace. A perennial loser over 5 or so seasons who drafts young like I do can't develop all the players under the 5/5/5/3/2 system. For example this year I drafted 3 17 year olds in the 1st round. I believe all 3 to be all star caliber players. But my team is still horrible. If I end up with a top pick again next season how can I develop another player if there isnt a major league ready player? Or what if the best prospect is also 17? The current training system would leave one of these players under trained.Plus, it isn't a disadvantage. I believe when it's my turn to buy cps I pay a handsome rate for them. And when it cycles to where I sell those cps I get very valuable veterans to compliment my team. I thinks it's an effective tool to buy and sell an asset. And yes I understand the argument that real teams don't sell off their coaching and an opposing team doesn't train another teams players. But in real life every organization isn't made to limit the amount of players that can grow every year they try to nurture everyone equally.
Again, it is the most ideal situation? No. Can I understand the other side of the argument? Yes.
shieldagent
July 16, 2013 at 09:12PM View BBCode
Yes Moustique it's a fun game. I hope to bring my team to a good level without making too many mistakes. Doing baby steps at first but I feel more comfortable nowPages: 1