July 19, 2009 at 03:27AM View BBCode
WE HAVE OUR FIRST UPDATE..it appears that TYson is gone this weekend..we should know more about our application status soon.July 19, 2009 at 03:30AM View BBCode
TO add:July 19, 2009 at 01:01PM View BBCode
I have the same question as Swampy re: what is Rule 5 draft, but this sounds really interesting, I would def consider it.July 19, 2009 at 02:56PM View BBCode
A rule 5 draft is a prospect draft held every once in a while. Teams would designate a certain amount of players available to be drafted by teams from their minor leagues. After two or three of those players have been selected, we would make the rest of your players exempt from drafting.July 19, 2009 at 04:55PM View BBCode
Can you maybe explain how this is beneficial? I guess i don't get it, you mean every few season, we have to put our own minor leaguers up for a draft? how does that affect rebuilds?July 19, 2009 at 05:26PM View BBCode
So you put up your crappiest minor leaguers, everyone else does as well, and you select someone else's crappy minor leaguers? What's the benefit of that? No one is going to lose good minor leaguers or even marginal ones to a Rule V.July 19, 2009 at 05:43PM View BBCode
some mightJuly 19, 2009 at 05:45PM View BBCode
But do you pick the players that are exposed to Rule 5? What is the process for picking them? Like over age 24? That would make sense to me since if a player is 24 and still in the minors there's probably not room for him on the roster. And will you have to keep the Rule 5 on your 25 man MLB roster the whole season or lose him, like in MLB?July 19, 2009 at 05:46PM View BBCode
it would be further beneficial because there will definitely be a minimum loss penalty or lottery or both...creating more of a need for those b-/b players that arent usually worth trading for..July 19, 2009 at 05:50PM View BBCode
As long as owners aren't putting up waiver wire players, that's why I'm curious as to who would be exposed. Teams do stockpile talent occasionally in the minors and this would redistribute some talent other teams could use in majors. That's why picking that talent would be vital as opposed to teams just putting up the dregs of their minors or getting guys from the waiver wire and exposing them to the draft, which no one needs.July 19, 2009 at 05:50PM View BBCode
by lemaster
But do you the players that are exposed to 5? the process for picking them? Like over age 24? That would make sense to me since if a player is 24 and still in the minors there's probably not room for him on the roster. And will you have to keep the 5 on your 25 man MLB roster the whole season or lose him, like in MLB?
July 19, 2009 at 05:53PM View BBCode
by lemaster
As long as owners aren't up waiver , that's why I'm curious as to who would be exposed. Teams do stockpile talent occasionally in the minors and this would redistribute some talent other teams could use in majors. That's why picking that talent would be vital as opposed to teams just putting up the dregs of their minors or getting guys from the waiver wire and exposing them to the draft, which no one needs.
July 19, 2009 at 05:54PM View BBCode
Every team can exempt 5 of their 15 minor leaguers. The other 10 are exposed to the draft and up to 2 or 3 (you'll have to decide) can be plucked by other teams. Once the 2 or 3 are plucked, you can't lose any more.July 19, 2009 at 05:57PM View BBCode
Yeah I was thinkin about that...July 19, 2009 at 05:59PM View BBCode
Also, all interested owners should see the thread in Private League Information...u2u me or say it here, or u2u thaceo to reserve your spot...July 20, 2009 at 06:52AM View BBCode
Originally posted by INDIANSFORLIFE
by lemaster
But do you the players that are exposed to 5? the process for picking them? Like over age 24? That would make sense to me since if a player is 24 and still in the minors there's probably not room for him on the roster. And will you have to keep the 5 on your 25 man MLB roster the whole season or lose him, like in MLB?
Yeah. You would pick your own list of 7 players. No other requirements. If you have 2 or 3 of them drafted (undecided) then the rest would be exempt..
Wouldnt have to keep them on the major league roster. The draft would probably be done by message board if no technology is developed...
July 20, 2009 at 06:58AM View BBCode
Originally posted by Svvamprat
Originally posted by INDIANSFORLIFE
by lemaster
But do you the players that are exposed to 5? the process for picking them? Like over age 24? That would make sense to me since if a player is 24 and still in the minors there's probably not room for him on the roster. And will you have to keep the 5 on your 25 man MLB roster the whole season or lose him, like in MLB?
Yeah. You would pick your own list of 7 players. No other requirements. If you have 2 or 3 of them drafted (undecided) then the rest would be exempt..
Wouldnt have to keep them on the major league roster. The draft would probably be done by message board if no technology is developed...
It's flawed you can't have an owner pick 7 of his own players. What would stop an owner from picking up waiver wire trash before the deadline and saying here are my 7? Besides there are no B- or even B guys mid 20s worth using in a CP 3 league. CP 3 leagues are just different animals all together. What you have in a mature CP 3 league is alot of B+ overall players from any age range and even some teams carrying 2 or more A- overall guys in the minors. There has to be a better way to carry this out.
July 20, 2009 at 02:20PM View BBCode
The roster freeze and player ineligibility would stop those things.Plus there would only be 2 rounds in the draft...July 20, 2009 at 03:48PM View BBCode
Originally posted by INDIANSFORLIFE
The roster freeze and player ineligibility would stop those things.Plus there would only be 2 rounds in the draft...
But it hasnt been accepted yet anyway so it might be a moot point.
July 20, 2009 at 06:26PM View BBCode
Originally posted by Svvamprat
Originally posted by INDIANSFORLIFE
The roster freeze and player ineligibility would stop those things.Plus there would only be 2 rounds in the draft...
But it hasnt been accepted yet anyway so it might be a moot point.
Rule 5 won't be accepted because of the work involved that an admin would have to do. First the guys in the B league would have to select a player to be converted. If your going to draft 2 deep then they would have to choose 2 players. Then the admin would copy player X(a league player) to player Y(player chosen by the B league). To get 32 owners to respond in a timely manor would be impossible. Take away rule 5 and this league has a better chance.
Pages: 1