 |
View Old Forum Thread
TheBigKahuna0
Below are the position player HOF nominees. In an effort to keep the ballot short, I have the absolute best to offer here but I also probably missed a few guys. If I missed someone that should be nominated, post those names along with your vote. After the first two rounds, we'll do a HOF run off for the extra nominees.
To get in on this special ballot, 75% of the vote is required. That is, 75% of votes cast gets you in and anyone who does not vote will not be held against the players. This is a one shot chance (then we can get to multiple ballot votes) for this list. Here are your nominees by position:
Catcher:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9323938]Jerry Lamm[/url] - STL
423 HR's, 2640 Hits, 1774 RBI's, 13 time All-Star, 7 time champion, 6 gold gloves
Lamm may be the best hitting catcher we've ever seen. He earned all 13 all-star nods in a row and won 4 gold gloves in a row. Lamm retired in 2008.
First Base:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10176110]Danny Dressen[/url] - CIN
433 HR's, 2703 Hits, 1663 RBI's, 428SB's, 2008 MVP, 11 time All-Star, 9 gold gloves
Dressen managed a well-balanced career that included over 400 HR's and 400 SB's. He put aside the notion of first basemen acting as defensive liabilities while collecting 6 gold gloves, including #2 of 3 in a row during his 2008 MVP season
Second Base:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9022641]KC Dilla[/url] - BOS
435 HR's, 2620 Hits, 1574 RBI's, 3 time MVP, 10 time All-Star, 4 time champion
Dilla followed his franchise around to three cities, from New York to Baltimore to Boston, racking up accolades as he went. Dilla won 3 MVP awards including a Triple Crown season in 2004.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=10176141]Marty Hardgrove[/url] - SEA
365 HR's, 2880 Hits, 1408 RBI's, 364 SB's, 9 time all-star, 2 time champion, 5 gold gloves
Hargrove had a run of dominance from 2005 to 2013 where he was an all-star every year and won 4 of his 5 gold gloves. This solid table setter finished with over 1500 runs while falling just 120 hits short of 3000.
Shortstop:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8699517]Jose Cassini[/url] - COL
481 HR's, 2704 Hits, 1662 RBI's, 525 SB, 3 time MVP (back to back '01-'02), 8 time All-Star, 5 time champion, 6 gold gloves
While Cassini wears a Colorado hat, he played the majority of his career in the team's former location as the New York Knights. Cassini won the MVP award in his third season. When he was dealt to the St Louis Browns in 2000, he approached the games with a new ferocity winning the MVP in 01 and 02. This included the Triple Crown in 2002. Meanwhile he collected 6 gold gloves along the way.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10072189&statsorimps=stats]Chief Hand[/url] - SEA
345 HR's, 2549 Hits, 1415 RBI's, 197 SB's, 2 time MVP, 8 time all-star, 3 time champion, 2 gold gloves
Chief was once traded twice in 2002 while still regarded as a rough prospect. He took off from there, earning his first of 8 all-star appearances just two years later. He won the MVP in 2007 and collected a World Series ring with the Steelheads. When things fell apart in Seattle, Hand found himself on the upstart Miami Yams where he captured the 2012 MVP and two more titles.
Left Field:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9171578]Candy Boyle[/url] - KC
199 HR's, 2972 Hits, 999 RBI's, 626 SB's (8th), 4 time All-Star, 9 gold gloves
Boyle lacked the regular all-star recognition many of his ilk received, but made up for that with blazing speed and great defense. He ended up 8th all time in stolen bases and 16th in hits. The valuable leadoff man is also 7th all time in walks.
Center Field:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9556134]Joe Watkins[/url] - MIA
505 HR's, 3021 Hits, 1778 RBI's, 359 SB's, 2 time MVP, 11 time All-Star, 3 time champion, 2 gold gloves
The franchise Yam is in both the 500 HR and 3000 hit clubs. Watkins led the league in HR's three times and was the all-star starter 10 years in a row. He was traded in his prime and didn't disappoint with 2 MVP awards and three titles.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9323934]Steve Best[/url] - STL
171 HR's, 3089 Hits (10th), 1848 Runs (5th), 891 SB's (1st), 9 time All-Star, 7 time champion, 1 gold glove
Steve could be the best leadoff man of all time. He finished 10th in hits, 5th in runs and 1st in stolen bases. He led the league in SB's 9 times and holds the single season record (70). Don't forget his 1286 walks that are good for 3rd all-time.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=10072140]Roger Goodson[/url] - WAS
359 HR's, 2662 hits, 1466 RBI's, 433 SB's, '08 MVP, 8 time all-star, 3 gold gloves
Goodson had an 8 year run as an all-star every year plus an MVP award and his 3 gold gloves. Outside of that time he was still a great player for the Halos, but nothing matches that stretch of domination. Goodson did not manage to capture a title, although he took the Halos to the series 3 times in his career.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=9805512]Joe Rodriguez[/url] - KC
349 HR's, 2787 hits, 1565 RBI's, 467 SB's, 6 time All-star, 6 gold gloves
Like Goodson, Rodriguez was never able to win a World Series, but took his team to three. After a slow start to his career, he became an annual all-star for the Monarchs before being traded to Cincy in 2009. Even as his career waned, he still provided top notch defense scoring three straight gold gloves in his last three full seasons.
Right Field:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8699578]Jonson Heyward[/url] - CLE
542 HR's (4th), 3024 hits, 1879 RBI's (2nd) 453 SB's, 4 time MVP, 10 time all-star, 7 gold gloves
Heyward dominated the American League for the duration of his career. He followed a rookie of the year campaign with an MVP award, his first of 4. He added in 7 gold gloves and 4 AL pennants, although never hoisted the big trophy.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=9323973]Zach Atwood[/url] - WAS
Atwood was a solid Halo and a big part of their success in the 2000's. Atwood played at a time where the outfield positions were their strongest, limiting him to just 4 all-star appearances. Atwood finished with over 2500 hits and nearly 500 stolen bases.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=10176140]Ben Fisher[/url] - SEA
312 HR's, 2871 hits, 1356 RBI's, 360 SB's, 2 time MVP (back to back '09 - '10), 7 time all-star, 1 time champion, 1 gold glove
Fisher enjoyed a great run in Seattle that ended with back to back MVP awards. Fisher always seemed to hit for a good average while providing good power for a middle of the order bat. He was traded to Pittsburgh after his MVP seasons where he collected his only gold glove but failed to recapture his offensive dominance from the 2000's.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=9934170]Jose Reyes[/url] - KC
364 HR's, 2878 hits, 1513 RBI's, 452 SB's, '03 MVP, 6 time all-star, 1 gold glove
Reyes had a dominate 7 year period, earning 6 all-star nods and was an injury away from a 7th. He was the 2003 MVP/Gold Glove/Batting Champion and played in the playoffs 10 times, although his .256 playoff average wasn't enough to get him a ring.
HOF Catch Up Vote
October 25, 2016 at 09:45PM View BBCode
It's been a while since we did any HOF voting (15 seasons) and in an effort to get things back up to a regular yearly event, here's one big catch up ballot. Actually, it'll be two ballots - one now for position players then another later for pitchers. We'll do this quickly to get through both groups, ballots will be counted Nov 1 then pitchers will be nominated.Below are the position player HOF nominees. In an effort to keep the ballot short, I have the absolute best to offer here but I also probably missed a few guys. If I missed someone that should be nominated, post those names along with your vote. After the first two rounds, we'll do a HOF run off for the extra nominees.
To get in on this special ballot, 75% of the vote is required. That is, 75% of votes cast gets you in and anyone who does not vote will not be held against the players. This is a one shot chance (then we can get to multiple ballot votes) for this list. Here are your nominees by position:
Catcher:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9323938]Jerry Lamm[/url] - STL
423 HR's, 2640 Hits, 1774 RBI's, 13 time All-Star, 7 time champion, 6 gold gloves
Lamm may be the best hitting catcher we've ever seen. He earned all 13 all-star nods in a row and won 4 gold gloves in a row. Lamm retired in 2008.
First Base:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10176110]Danny Dressen[/url] - CIN
433 HR's, 2703 Hits, 1663 RBI's, 428SB's, 2008 MVP, 11 time All-Star, 9 gold gloves
Dressen managed a well-balanced career that included over 400 HR's and 400 SB's. He put aside the notion of first basemen acting as defensive liabilities while collecting 6 gold gloves, including #2 of 3 in a row during his 2008 MVP season
Second Base:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9022641]KC Dilla[/url] - BOS
435 HR's, 2620 Hits, 1574 RBI's, 3 time MVP, 10 time All-Star, 4 time champion
Dilla followed his franchise around to three cities, from New York to Baltimore to Boston, racking up accolades as he went. Dilla won 3 MVP awards including a Triple Crown season in 2004.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=10176141]Marty Hardgrove[/url] - SEA
365 HR's, 2880 Hits, 1408 RBI's, 364 SB's, 9 time all-star, 2 time champion, 5 gold gloves
Hargrove had a run of dominance from 2005 to 2013 where he was an all-star every year and won 4 of his 5 gold gloves. This solid table setter finished with over 1500 runs while falling just 120 hits short of 3000.
Shortstop:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8699517]Jose Cassini[/url] - COL
481 HR's, 2704 Hits, 1662 RBI's, 525 SB, 3 time MVP (back to back '01-'02), 8 time All-Star, 5 time champion, 6 gold gloves
While Cassini wears a Colorado hat, he played the majority of his career in the team's former location as the New York Knights. Cassini won the MVP award in his third season. When he was dealt to the St Louis Browns in 2000, he approached the games with a new ferocity winning the MVP in 01 and 02. This included the Triple Crown in 2002. Meanwhile he collected 6 gold gloves along the way.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10072189&statsorimps=stats]Chief Hand[/url] - SEA
345 HR's, 2549 Hits, 1415 RBI's, 197 SB's, 2 time MVP, 8 time all-star, 3 time champion, 2 gold gloves
Chief was once traded twice in 2002 while still regarded as a rough prospect. He took off from there, earning his first of 8 all-star appearances just two years later. He won the MVP in 2007 and collected a World Series ring with the Steelheads. When things fell apart in Seattle, Hand found himself on the upstart Miami Yams where he captured the 2012 MVP and two more titles.
Left Field:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9171578]Candy Boyle[/url] - KC
199 HR's, 2972 Hits, 999 RBI's, 626 SB's (8th), 4 time All-Star, 9 gold gloves
Boyle lacked the regular all-star recognition many of his ilk received, but made up for that with blazing speed and great defense. He ended up 8th all time in stolen bases and 16th in hits. The valuable leadoff man is also 7th all time in walks.
Center Field:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9556134]Joe Watkins[/url] - MIA
505 HR's, 3021 Hits, 1778 RBI's, 359 SB's, 2 time MVP, 11 time All-Star, 3 time champion, 2 gold gloves
The franchise Yam is in both the 500 HR and 3000 hit clubs. Watkins led the league in HR's three times and was the all-star starter 10 years in a row. He was traded in his prime and didn't disappoint with 2 MVP awards and three titles.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9323934]Steve Best[/url] - STL
171 HR's, 3089 Hits (10th), 1848 Runs (5th), 891 SB's (1st), 9 time All-Star, 7 time champion, 1 gold glove
Steve could be the best leadoff man of all time. He finished 10th in hits, 5th in runs and 1st in stolen bases. He led the league in SB's 9 times and holds the single season record (70). Don't forget his 1286 walks that are good for 3rd all-time.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=10072140]Roger Goodson[/url] - WAS
359 HR's, 2662 hits, 1466 RBI's, 433 SB's, '08 MVP, 8 time all-star, 3 gold gloves
Goodson had an 8 year run as an all-star every year plus an MVP award and his 3 gold gloves. Outside of that time he was still a great player for the Halos, but nothing matches that stretch of domination. Goodson did not manage to capture a title, although he took the Halos to the series 3 times in his career.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=9805512]Joe Rodriguez[/url] - KC
349 HR's, 2787 hits, 1565 RBI's, 467 SB's, 6 time All-star, 6 gold gloves
Like Goodson, Rodriguez was never able to win a World Series, but took his team to three. After a slow start to his career, he became an annual all-star for the Monarchs before being traded to Cincy in 2009. Even as his career waned, he still provided top notch defense scoring three straight gold gloves in his last three full seasons.
Right Field:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8699578]Jonson Heyward[/url] - CLE
542 HR's (4th), 3024 hits, 1879 RBI's (2nd) 453 SB's, 4 time MVP, 10 time all-star, 7 gold gloves
Heyward dominated the American League for the duration of his career. He followed a rookie of the year campaign with an MVP award, his first of 4. He added in 7 gold gloves and 4 AL pennants, although never hoisted the big trophy.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=9323973]Zach Atwood[/url] - WAS
Atwood was a solid Halo and a big part of their success in the 2000's. Atwood played at a time where the outfield positions were their strongest, limiting him to just 4 all-star appearances. Atwood finished with over 2500 hits and nearly 500 stolen bases.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=10176140]Ben Fisher[/url] - SEA
312 HR's, 2871 hits, 1356 RBI's, 360 SB's, 2 time MVP (back to back '09 - '10), 7 time all-star, 1 time champion, 1 gold glove
Fisher enjoyed a great run in Seattle that ended with back to back MVP awards. Fisher always seemed to hit for a good average while providing good power for a middle of the order bat. He was traded to Pittsburgh after his MVP seasons where he collected his only gold glove but failed to recapture his offensive dominance from the 2000's.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?player=nobody&mode=stats&id=9934170]Jose Reyes[/url] - KC
364 HR's, 2878 hits, 1513 RBI's, 452 SB's, '03 MVP, 6 time all-star, 1 gold glove
Reyes had a dominate 7 year period, earning 6 all-star nods and was an injury away from a 7th. He was the 2003 MVP/Gold Glove/Batting Champion and played in the playoffs 10 times, although his .256 playoff average wasn't enough to get him a ring.
Santo10
Ken Hiser
Bob Davenport
Eddie Brown
Abe Delgado
Al Oliver
Ian Cognito
Bull Malarkey
October 26, 2016 at 02:56PM View BBCode
When we last voted these were the guys who were supposed to be considered on the next ballot...Ken Hiser
Bob Davenport
Eddie Brown
Abe Delgado
Al Oliver
Ian Cognito
Bull Malarkey
TheBigKahuna0
Already got some U2U questions. Vote for as many as you want in this ballot. Moving forward, we can have a discussion on how to handle the HOF. The important thing from my perspective is to get the ball rolling.
October 26, 2016 at 03:51PM View BBCode
I'll throw them on the run-off ballot. I'm assuming there will be more names to add to it.Already got some U2U questions. Vote for as many as you want in this ballot. Moving forward, we can have a discussion on how to handle the HOF. The important thing from my perspective is to get the ball rolling.
Santo10
My vote (the no-brainers):
Jerry Lamm
Danny Dressen
KC Dilla
Joe Cassini
Joe Watkins
Steve Best
Jonson Heyward
October 26, 2016 at 06:40PM View BBCode
Okay on the first run through, I am going to vote for the no-brainers only. I think almost everybody, if not everybody, on this list will get in by the second ballot.My vote (the no-brainers):
Jerry Lamm
Danny Dressen
KC Dilla
Joe Cassini
Joe Watkins
Steve Best
Jonson Heyward
Santo10
October 26, 2016 at 06:44PM View BBCode
Since catchers have an extremely hard time getting into the HOF in this league, I would include Fergy Malone in your run-off ballot.
TheBigKahuna0
I was planning on just doing one ballot for these guys (unlimited votes) but we'll add anyone with at least 50% to the run off. From there, we can decide if they should stay on the ballot in the normal voting. All this has the purpose of catching up on voting so we can current without an overwhelming annual ballot.
October 26, 2016 at 07:52PM View BBCode
Will do. When a catcher wins MVP you gotta nominate them.I was planning on just doing one ballot for these guys (unlimited votes) but we'll add anyone with at least 50% to the run off. From there, we can decide if they should stay on the ballot in the normal voting. All this has the purpose of catching up on voting so we can current without an overwhelming annual ballot.
TapMaster
Lamm
Dilla
Cassini
Watkins
Best
Heyward
October 27, 2016 at 01:30AM View BBCode
I vote for:Lamm
Dilla
Cassini
Watkins
Best
Heyward
Q_142857
Joe Watkins
KC Dilla
Danny Dressen
Jerry Lamm
Jonson Heyward
Jose Cassini
Chief Hand
I also propose to add these players onto the hitter runoff:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9171508]Damon Sead[/url] - 10 All-star teams, 1 MVP, 1 Gold Glove, consistent greatness. Also a higher OPS than anybody on the ballot except for Dilla.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9440867]Jason Thomasson[/url] - 11 All-star teams, 1 MVP, 1 Gold Glove, Rookie of the Year, and the same career OPS as Jose Cassini. Lost out on some playing time during his prime because his idiot manager (me) unnecessarily sacrificed him for additional mentoring.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10273919]Bobby Williams[/url] - Yeah another one of my own but: 8 All-star teams, 1 MVP, superb defender (2 Gold Gloves and +100 (!) at 2B), better career OPS than 2/3s of the current ballot. And all this despite being constantly injured.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10683841]Harry Gonzalez[/url] - 7 All-star teams, 4 Gold Gloves, comparable to Fergy Malone, who Santo suggested earlier for the runoff.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9323940]Art Foster[/url] - 9 All-star teams, 1 MVP, 1 Gold Glove, better career OPS than everybody on the ballot except Dilla.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=11201615]Jeison Hernandez[/url] - 7 All-Star teams, 4 Gold Gloves, Rookie of the Year. This would be a controversial pick as he entered the league late, but boy was he good.
You can see I'm more of a rate stats guy than a counting stats guy. At any rate, I think these players are at least as worthy as the bottom of this ballot.
[Edited on 10-27-2016 by Q_142857]
[Edited on 10-27-2016 by Q_142857]
October 27, 2016 at 02:37AM View BBCode
For this ballot, I vote:Joe Watkins
KC Dilla
Danny Dressen
Jerry Lamm
Jonson Heyward
Jose Cassini
Chief Hand
I also propose to add these players onto the hitter runoff:
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9171508]Damon Sead[/url] - 10 All-star teams, 1 MVP, 1 Gold Glove, consistent greatness. Also a higher OPS than anybody on the ballot except for Dilla.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9440867]Jason Thomasson[/url] - 11 All-star teams, 1 MVP, 1 Gold Glove, Rookie of the Year, and the same career OPS as Jose Cassini. Lost out on some playing time during his prime because his idiot manager (me) unnecessarily sacrificed him for additional mentoring.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10273919]Bobby Williams[/url] - Yeah another one of my own but: 8 All-star teams, 1 MVP, superb defender (2 Gold Gloves and +100 (!) at 2B), better career OPS than 2/3s of the current ballot. And all this despite being constantly injured.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10683841]Harry Gonzalez[/url] - 7 All-star teams, 4 Gold Gloves, comparable to Fergy Malone, who Santo suggested earlier for the runoff.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9323940]Art Foster[/url] - 9 All-star teams, 1 MVP, 1 Gold Glove, better career OPS than everybody on the ballot except Dilla.
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=11201615]Jeison Hernandez[/url] - 7 All-Star teams, 4 Gold Gloves, Rookie of the Year. This would be a controversial pick as he entered the league late, but boy was he good.
You can see I'm more of a rate stats guy than a counting stats guy. At any rate, I think these players are at least as worthy as the bottom of this ballot.
[Edited on 10-27-2016 by Q_142857]
[Edited on 10-27-2016 by Q_142857]
Santo10
October 27, 2016 at 01:32PM View BBCode
Just a note.... the criteria previously for election was 2/3rds of the vote. I know you said 3/4ths (which is the real HOF criteria) but with so few ballots it is tough to achieve.
danno38852
October 27, 2016 at 02:19PM View BBCode
Johnson Heyward, Joe Rodriguez, Joe Watkins, Candy Boyle,Jerry Lamm, Danny Dressen, Jose Cassini.
danno38852
October 27, 2016 at 02:20PM View BBCode
Johnson Heyward, Joe Rodriguez, Joe Watkins, Candy Boyle,Jerry Lamm, Danny Dressen, Jose Cassini.
winkabob
Dressen
Dilla
Hardgrove
Cassini
Watkins
Heyward
Reyes
and thanks for taking the time to do this stuff!
October 29, 2016 at 02:46PM View BBCode
LammDressen
Dilla
Hardgrove
Cassini
Watkins
Heyward
Reyes
and thanks for taking the time to do this stuff!
jose1717
October 30, 2016 at 12:08PM View BBCode
J.Lamm D.Dressen J.Cassini J.Watkins S.Best J.Howard
mrtwolff
Danny Dressen
KC Dilla
Joe Cassini
Joe Watkins
Steve Best
Jonson Heyward
October 30, 2016 at 06:07PM View BBCode
Jerry LammDanny Dressen
KC Dilla
Joe Cassini
Joe Watkins
Steve Best
Jonson Heyward
TheBigKahuna0
Dressen
Cassini
Dilla
Watkins
Best
Heyward
Boyle
Fisher
October 31, 2016 at 03:35PM View BBCode
LammDressen
Cassini
Dilla
Watkins
Best
Heyward
Boyle
Fisher
TheBigKahuna0
We'll go with the JJL of 2/3 vote as Santo pointed out. 50% stays on for the next round where we'll add all of the extra nominees.
October 31, 2016 at 03:42PM View BBCode
New ballot is out, but still one more day to vote here. Anything in before I get around to counting will be counted.We'll go with the JJL of 2/3 vote as Santo pointed out. 50% stays on for the next round where we'll add all of the extra nominees.
Santo10
Just so I help keep guys at 50% or more on the ballot, I want to add the following names to my initial ballot
Marty Hardgrove
Chief Hand
Roger Goodson
Joe Rodriguez
Ben Fisher
Jose Reyes
October 31, 2016 at 07:39PM View BBCode
I actually would like to see all of these guys back on the ballot, when they can compete in normal circumstances. This list was awesome, and it makes some of these guys "seem" not worthy. I think a case could be made for everyone on this list, and they would likely beat out the vast majority of new candidates.Just so I help keep guys at 50% or more on the ballot, I want to add the following names to my initial ballot
Marty Hardgrove
Chief Hand
Roger Goodson
Joe Rodriguez
Ben Fisher
Jose Reyes
Racepicks
Lamm
Dressen
Dilla
Heyward
Cassini
Watkins
Heyward
November 01, 2016 at 06:46PM View BBCode
Here's my ballot:Lamm
Dressen
Dilla
Heyward
Cassini
Watkins
Heyward
TheBigKahuna0
10 votes cast. 7 votes to get in. In the HOF:
Jonson Heyward (100%)
Jerry Lamm (100%)
Joe Watkins (100%)
Danny Dressen (90%)
KC Dilla (80%)
Jose Cassini (70%)
Missing out but they'll be back:
Steve Best (60%)
Ben Fisher (20%)
Candy Boyle (20%)
Chief Hand (20%)
Joe Cassini (20%)
Joe Rodriguez (20%)
Jose Reyes (20%)
Marty Hardgrove (20%)
Roger Goodson (10%)
Any more past nominees, get them in here. In the meantime, vote for pitchers and the run-off ballot is coming soon.
November 01, 2016 at 09:37PM View BBCode
Totals are in and you are a tough crowd! Based on Santo's suggestion that maybe having all of these guys on the same ballot make some look less than HOF, anyone receiving votes will go to the run off ballot. We'll set a threshold to get them on the normal ballot after that.10 votes cast. 7 votes to get in. In the HOF:
Jonson Heyward (100%)
Jerry Lamm (100%)
Joe Watkins (100%)
Danny Dressen (90%)
KC Dilla (80%)
Jose Cassini (70%)
Missing out but they'll be back:
Steve Best (60%)
Ben Fisher (20%)
Candy Boyle (20%)
Chief Hand (20%)
Joe Cassini (20%)
Joe Rodriguez (20%)
Jose Reyes (20%)
Marty Hardgrove (20%)
Roger Goodson (10%)
Any more past nominees, get them in here. In the meantime, vote for pitchers and the run-off ballot is coming soon.
Santo10
I think if you look at the guys who already in the HOF, most of these guys stack up pretty well. They at least should be in the conversation. It was a good move putting them back on the ballot for the next vote.
November 02, 2016 at 01:20PM View BBCode
Yes it is an extremely tough crowd. The All-Time Leader in Stolen Bases by over 100 and over 200 over the third place guy, didn't get in. That's like saying Ricky Henderson or Lou Brock shouldn't get in because they didn't hit 300 homers.I think if you look at the guys who already in the HOF, most of these guys stack up pretty well. They at least should be in the conversation. It was a good move putting them back on the ballot for the next vote.
Pages: 1