Sim Dynasty

View Old Forum Thread

Old Forum Index » Baseball League Forums » Dynasty Leagues » Joe Medwick League » ***2018 HOF Thread***
spicoli306

***2018 HOF Thread***

April 13, 2017 at 10:53PM View BBCode

Fellow JML owners, I've compiled a list of players as nominees for this year's ballot. Some are holdovers that previously received votes and some are new nominees that were either chosen by team owners or chosen by myself as worthy candidates.

Newly nominated candidates are: Del Schorr, Fred Pena, Jason Bosch, Dan Malis, Bill Murphy, Gus Mahaffey, J.R. Richard, Chet Donnelly, Jimmie Smalls, & Kurt Harris

As always, I'd like to encourage everyone to vote. I understand not every owner cares about the HOF voting. However, if you are a relatively new owner, do not feel that you are not justified to vote. Voting is best when it is a collaborative process involving as many owners as possible. Even though some owners have only been here for recent seasons, it is relatively simple to get an idea of past players with HOF-level careers. If unsure, I'd encourage owners to take a look at the list of players in the [url=http://www.simdynasty.com/hof.jsp?lid=351]JML HOF[/url].

This ballot had no Automatic Qualifiers, which are the statistic totals of:
500 HR
3000 H
300 W

You can vote for up to 10 players. You can vote for fewer. If you choose to vote for nobody, please declare that. Please announce your vote by replying to this thread on our league message board.

Players on 75% of the ballots cast will be enshrined into the Hall of Fame.

Players with an ** have each have been on 5+ ballots so far and have failed to reach induction; they will be dropped off the ballot if support does not increase with this vote.

Thanks for everyone's participation, Michael.

Nominees:
SP
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9442013]Bob Buchanan**[/url]
Bob pitched 15 seasons with STL, MON, and HOU.
He has 1 WS ring.
He won a Cy Young Award.
He was an 8 time All-Star.
He led the league in: Wins- 1 time, ERA- 1 time, WHIP- 1 time
He ranks:
46th all-time in Wins (223)
72nd all-time in CG (73)
78th all-time in SHO (16)
63rd all-time in ERA (3.48)
45th all-time in WHIP (1.20)
38th all-time in K?s (2776)

[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9172740]Casey Harris**[/url]
Casey pitched 15 seasons with DET.
He has 1 WS ring.
He won 3 Cy Young Awards.
He was a 7 time All-Star.
He led the league in: ERA- 3 times, Wins- 2 times
He ranks:
40th all-time in Wins (226)
64th all-time in CG (76)
39th all-time in ERA (3.34)
69th all-time in WHIP (1.22)
30th all-time in K?s (2880)

[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9441980]John Allerdyce**[/url]
John pitched 14 seasons with CHN, BOS, and SEA.
He has 2 WS rings.
He won a Cy Young Award.
He was a Rookie of the Year Award winner.
He was a 10 time All-Star.
He led the league in: K?s- 5 times, CG- 2 times
He ranks:
87th all-time in Wins (198)
20th all-time in CG (101)
38th all-time in SHO (22)
111th all-time in ERA (3.69)
18th all-time in K?s (3005)

[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10177120]Mike Crump[/url]
Mike pitched 16 seasons with HOU/ATL.
He has 3 WS rings.
He was a Rookie of the Year Award winner.
He was a 7 time All-Star.
He led the league in: WHIP- 4 times, ERA- 1 time
He ranks:
101st all-time in Wins (188)
31st all-time in ERA (3.30)
21st all-time in WHIP (1.16)

[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10846572]Del Schorr[/url]
Del pitched 16 seasons with CHA.
He has 2 WS rings.
He won 2 Cy Young Awards.
He was a 7 time All-Star.
He led the league in: SHO- 4 times, ERA- 1 time, Wins- 1 time, CG- 1 time
He ranks:
21st all-time in Wins (247)
3rd all-time in CG (127)
4th all-time in SHO (42)
25th all-time in ERA (3.24)
43rd all-time in WHIP (1.20)
10th all-time in K?s (3118)

[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10684759]Bill Murphy[/url]
Bill pitched 15 seasons with SEA.
He has 3 WS rings.
He won 3 Cy Young Awards.
He was a 5 time All-Star.
He led the league in: ERA- 1 time, SHO- 1 time
He ranks:
26th all-time in Wins (238)
29th all-time in CG (96)
19th all-time in SHO (26)
43rd all-time in ERA (3.38)
73rd all-time in WHIP (1.22)
29th all-time in K?s (2887)

[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10587947]J.R. Richard[/url]
J.R. pitched 15 seasons with HOU/ATL and LAN.
He has 3 WS rings.
He was a 2 time All-Star.
He led the league in: K's- 1 time
He ranks:
105th all-time in Wins (187)
143rd all-time in K?s (2144)

[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10684756]Chet Donnelly[/url]
Chet pitched 15 seasons with CHA.
He has 2 WS rings.
He won 2 Cy Young Awards.
He was a 6 time All-Star.
He led the league in: K's- 3 times, SHO- 3 times, Wins- 2 times, CG- 1 time
He ranks:
25th all-time in Wins (240)
15th all-time in CG (105)
5th all-time in SHO (40)
57th all-time in ERA (3.44)
116th all-time in WHIP (1.26)
7th all-time in K?s (3176)

RP
[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9806469]Joe Sherry[/url]
Joe pitched 18 seasons with TOR, MIN, and BAL.
He has 1 WS ring.
He won a Fireman Award.
He was a 9 time All-Star.
He never led the league in any significant catagory.
He ranks:
9th all-time in Saves (459)

C
[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9806526]Bill Khalifa[/url]
Bill was a Catcher/RF for 18 seasons with BOS.
He has 1 WS ring.
He was a 10 time All-Star.
He led the league in: SB- 1 time, 3B- 1 time
He ranks:
78th all-time in Hits (2522)
115th all-time in RBI?s (1224)
88th all-time in Runs (1372)
67th all-time in OBP (.366)
107th all-time in BA (.288)
40th all-time in SB?s (429)
101st all-time in 2B?s (402)
108th all-time in 3B?s (92)
44th all-time in BB?s (1049)

[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10934539]Fred Pena[/url]
Fred was a Catcher for 14 seasons with CHA.
He has 2 WS rings.
He was a 2 time All-Star.
He won 10 Gold Gloves.
He never led the league in any significant catagory.
He doesn?t rank in the Top 150 all-time in any significant category.

[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10381391]Jason Bosch[/url]
Jason was a Catcher for 16 seasons with STL.
He was a 10 time All-Star.
He won 1 Gold Glove.
He led the league in: Runs- 2 times, AVG- 1 time, OBP- 1 time, BB?s- 1 time
He ranks:
133rd all-time in Runs (1276)
25th all-time in OBP (.376)
87th all-time in OPS (.832)
49th all-time in BA (.296)
127th all-time in 2B?s (382)
85th all-time in BB?s (917)

1B
[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9023729]Doc Tomberlin**[/url]
Doc was a 1st Baseman for 16 seasons with DET.
He has 1 WS ring.
He won 1 MVP Award.
He was a 7 time All-Star.
He won 3 Gold Gloves.
He led the league in: OBP- 2 times, Runs- 1 time, 3B- 1 time, OPS- 1 time, AVG- 1 time
He ranks:
142nd all-time in HR?s (293)
134th all-time in Hits (2291)
150th all-time in RBI?s (1161)
127th all-time in Runs (1291)
34th all-time in SLG % (.500)
13th all-time in OBP (.382)
18th all-time in OPS (.882)
15th all-time in BA (.307)
133rd all-time in 2B?s (378)
105th all-time in 3B?s (93)
103rd all-time in BB?s (892)

[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10177135]Ducky Pettee[/url]
Ducky was a 1st Baseman for 18 seasons with MIL.
He won 8 Gold Gloves.
He never led the league in any significant catagory.
He ranks:
68th all-time in HR?s (351)
150th all-time in Hits (2236)
91st all-time in RBI?s (1286)

[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10767679]Gus Mahaffey[/url]
Gus was a 1st Baseman/CF/LF for 17 seasons with SEA, MIL, & PHI.
He was a 3 time All-Star.
He won 3 Gold Gloves.
He led the league in: 3B- 2 times
He ranks:
94th all-time in Hits (2455)
115th all-time in RBI?s (1224)
148th all-time in Runs (1241)
43rd all-time in 3B?s (109)

[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10587932]Jimmie Smalls[/url]
Jimmie was a 1st Baseman/3B for 16 seasons with STL & CHN.
He has 1 WS ring.
He was a 7 time All-Star.
He won 2 Gold Gloves.
He led the league in: OPS- 1 time, SLG%- 1 time
He ranks:
73rd all-time in HR?s (345)
89th all-time in RBI?s (1295)
118th all-time in SLG % (.474)

2B
[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9935200]Steve McCormick[/url]
Steve was a 2nd Baseman/3B/RF for 16 seasons with TOR.
He has 1 WS ring.
He was a 7 time All-Star.
He won 5 Gold Gloves.
He led the league in: Hits- 4 times, Runs- 2 times, BB?s- 2 times, 2B- 1 time
He ranks:
126th all-time in HR?s (300)
34th all-time in Hits (2816)
136th all-time in RBI?s (1189)
28th all-time in Runs (1631)
145th all-time in SB?s (296)
31st all-time in 2B?s (468)
27th all-time in BB?s (1118)

[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10476967]Kurt Harris[/url]
Kurt was a 2nd Baseman/3B for 17 seasons with STL.
He won 1 MVP Award.
He was a 9 time All-Star.
He won 2 Gold Gloves.
He led the league in: BB?s- 4 times, Runs- 1 time
He ranks:
72nd all-time in Hits (2563)
49th all-time in Runs (1526)
45th all-time in OBP (.371)
92nd all-time in BA (.290)
37th all-time in 2B?s (459)
24th all-time in BB?s (1126)

SS
[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8870986]Duke Mulvey**[/url]
Duke was a Shortstop/1B/3B/2B for 15 seasons with DET and MON.
He has 1 WS ring.
He was a Rookie of the Year Award winner.
He was a 9 time All-Star.
He won 3 Gold Gloves.
He led the league in: Runs- 2 times, Hits- 1 time, 2B- 1 time, 3B- 1 time, RBI- 1 time, BB?s- 1 time, SLG%- 1 time
He ranks:
98th all-time in HR's (324)
67th all-time in Hits (2580)
97th all-time in RBI?s (1262)
38th all-time in Runs (1589)
108th all-time in SLG % (.476)
128th all-time in OBP (.358)
84th all-time in OPS (.833)
96th all-time in BA (.290)
76th all-time in 2B?s (421)
10th all-time in 3B?s (130)
86th all-time in BB?s (916)

[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9935185]Ed Maddox[/url]
Ed was a Shortstop/2B for 18 seasons with HOU/ATL.
He has 3 WS rings.
He won 1 MVP Award.
He was a 9 time All-Star.
He won 5 Gold Gloves.
He never led the league in any significant catagory.
He ranks:
80th all-time in HR?s (338)
61st all-time in Hits (2609)
83rd all-time in RBI?s (1312)
73rd all-time in Runs (1406)
61st all-time in 2B?s (435)
104th all-time in BB?s (890)

[url=http://simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=10767681]Dan Malis[/url]
Dan was a Shortstop for 16 seasons with STL.
He was an 8 time All-Star.
He never led the league in any significant catagory.
He ranks:
149th all-time in HR?s (289)
65th all-time in RBI?s (1364)
114th all-time in 2B?s (389)

CF
[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9682842]Jim Gardner[/url]
Jim was a Centerfielder/RF/LF for 18 seasons with CHN, SEA, and MIL.
He has 2 WS rings.
He was a Rookie of the Year Award winner.
He was a 6 time All-Star.
He won 4 Gold Gloves.
He led the league in: SB- 3 times, Runs- 2 times
He ranks:
47th all-time in Hits (2739)
23rd all-time in Runs (1663)
1st all-time in SB?s (632)
52nd all-time in 2B?s (444)
19th all-time in 3B?s (121)
55th all-time in BB?s (1022)
Lyrici17

April 14, 2017 at 01:13AM View BBCode

Montreal votes for:

Jim Gardner
Steve McCormick
Chet Donnelly
Bill Murphy
Del Schorr
John Allerdyce
Casey Harris
Bob Buchanan
J.R. Richard
Kurt Harris
BCNEvan

April 14, 2017 at 03:02AM View BBCode

Casey Harris
Duke Mulvey
Bill Khalifa
Bob Buchanan
Doc Tomberlin
Jason Bosch
Chet Donnelly
Bill Murphy
Del Schorr
junghwaowh

April 15, 2017 at 10:20PM View BBCode

Milwaukee Marshals vote for
Casey Harris
John Allerdyce
Del Schorr
Bill Murphy
Chet Donnelly
Bill Khalifa
Doc Tomberlin
Steve McCormick
Kurt Harris
Ed Maddox
anhjohn

April 16, 2017 at 12:25PM View BBCode

Del Schorr
Jim Gardner
Casey Harris
Chet Donnelly
Duke Mulvey
machoking

April 22, 2017 at 10:35PM View BBCode

Harris
Schorr
Murphy
Donnelly
Gardner
crewdog

April 26, 2017 at 12:49AM View BBCode

Cincinnati votes for:

Jim Gardner
Steve McCormick
Chet Donnelly
Bill Murphy
Del Schorr
Casey Harris
spicoli306

April 28, 2017 at 01:14AM View BBCode

Boston votes for:

1) Bill Khalifa
2) Casey Harris
3) Duke Mulvey
4) Jim Gardner
5) Bob Buchanan
6) John Allerdyce
7) Doc Tomberlin
8) Del Schorr
9) Bill Murphy
10) Chet Donnelly
Wookieboy

May 05, 2017 at 04:42AM View BBCode

Schorr
Murphy
Donnelly
Khalifa
Gardener
Mulvey
Tomberlin
Harris
Buchanan
Alrrdyce
spicoli306

May 23, 2017 at 10:46PM View BBCode

Thanks to everyone who voted. Since this has been open for more than a month, I'm going to assume everyone who wanted to vote has done so. I'll be posting the inductees tonight.

Pages: 1