 |
View Old Forum Thread
Old Forum Index » Other Stuff » Sports Talk » Return of the brackets-SP edition-Walter Johnson wins
barterer2002
bold players have advanced and votes for either in that pairing will not be counted
Here are the brackets
Region I. 1871-1920
1. Christy Mathewson (Benne, Scooterpie, Bart)
16. Mickey Welsh
8. Joe McGinnity (bart, jchell, Scooterpie)
9. Jack Chesbro (Ham)
5. Three Finger Brown (chi925a, Brown, happy)
12. Tim Keefe
4. John Clarkson (jchell, chi925)
13. Rube Waddell (scooterpie, bart, happy)
3. Kid Nichols (Benne, foli, jchell)
14. Rube Marquard (Bart)
6. Al Spalding (Bart, Jug, ME)
11. Pud Galvin (Foli)
7. Ed Walsh (ME, scooterpie, Dirt)
10. Old Hoss Radborne (happy, jchell)
2. Cy Young (Jughead, Benne, Yar, happy)
15. Amos Russie
Region II 1900-1945
1. Walter Johnson (happy, scooterpie, Bart)
16. Red Ruffing
8. Burleigh Grimes (Benne, bart, foli)
9. Eddie Cicotte (scooterpie)
5. Dizzy Dean (Jughead, happy, Dirt)
12. Red Faber (ME, jchell)
4. Eddie Plank (Jchell, Jug, scooterpie)
13. Wes Ferrell (ME)
3. Grover Cleveland "Pete" Alexander (Bart, scooterpie, Benne, chi925, happy)
14. Wilber Cooper
6. Carl Hubbell (Dirt, Jchell, Yar, Foli)
11. Stan Coveleski
7. Dazzy Vance (Ham, foli, Bart)
10. Carl Mays
2. Lefty Grove (Benne, chi925a, happy)
15. Ted Lyons
Region III 1935-1975
1. Warren Spahn (happy, Dirt, Bart)
16. Lon Warneke
8. Whitey Ford (Benne, ME)
9. Don Drysdale (jchell, Yar, dirt)
5. Juan Marichal (jughead, happy, Benne, Fooli, Chi915)
12. Don Newcombe
4. Robin Roberts (Bart, jchell, happy
13. Hal Newhouser
3. Bob Gibson (chi925a, scooterpie, foli)
14. Jim Bunning
6. Bob Feller (Benne, bart, Jug)
11. Lefty Gomez
7. Early Wynn (scooterpie, jchell, bart)
10. Bob Lemon (happy, ME)
2. Sandy Koufax (Ham, Bart, scooterpie)
15. Billy Pierce
Region IV 1965-2008
1. Tom Seaver (Bart, foli, jchell)
16. Luis Tiant
8. Gaylord Perry (ME, chi925a, happy)
9. Tom Glavine (scooterpie)
5. Steve Carlton (Dirt, Bart, Benne)
12. Nolan Ryan
4. Greg Maddux (Ham, chi925a, dirt)
13. Don Sutton
3. Randy Johnson (Benne, happy, jchell, bart)
14. Bert Blyleven (Jughead)
6. Pedro Martinez (happy, Yar, ME)
11. Phil Niekro (Jug)
7. Jim Palmer (scooterpie, Foli, happy)
10. Fergie Jenkins
2. Roger Clemens (bart, scooterpie, Benne)
15. Tommy John (jchell)
ROUND 2
Region I
1. Christy Mathewson (Jug, Scooterpie, Bart)
8. Joe McGinnity
5. Three Finger Brown (happy, jchell, scooterpie)
13. Rube Waddell
3. Kid Nichols
6. Al Spalding (bart, happy, scooterpie)
7. Ed Walsh (ham)
2. Cy Young (Benne, dirt, jchell)
Region II
1. Walter Johnson (happy, bart, scooterpie)
8. Burleigh Grimes
5. Dizzy Dean (happy, Bart, Foli)
4. Eddie Plank (jchell, scooterpie)
3. Grover Cleveland Alexander (ham, bart, dirt)
6. Carl Hubbell
7. Dazzy Vance
2. Lefty Grove (jug, scooterpie, Benne)
Region III
1. Warren Spahn (bart, happy, scooterpie)
9. Don Drysdale
5. Juan Marichal (scooterpie, jchell, Foli)
4. Robin Roberts (happy, Bart)
3. Bob Gibson (scooterpie, jug, Ham)
6. Bob Feller (jchell, dirt)
7. Early Wynn
2. Sandy Koufax (ham, Benne, bart)
Region IV
1. Tom Seaver (bart, scooterpie. jchell)
8. Gaylord Perry
5. Steve Carlton (scooterpie)
4. Greg Maddux (Ham, jchell, happy)
3. Randy Johnson (jchell, Benne, bart)
6. Pedro Martinez (happy, scooterpie)
7. Jim Palmer (happy)
2. Roger Clemens (Jug, dirt, bart)
The Sweet 16
Region I
1. Christy Mathewson (dirt, scooterpie, Jug)
5. Three Finger Brown (happy, chi)
6. Al Spalding (ham)
2. Cy Young (scooterpie, dirt, bart)
Region II
1. Walter Johnson (tm, scooterpie, dirt)
5. Dizzy Dean (jug)
3. Grover Cleveland Alexander (ham)
2. Lefty Grove (happy, bart, tm)
Region III
1. Warren Spahn (Benne, spahn, bart)
5. Juan Marichal (foli)
3. Bob Gibson (jug, scooterpie, tm)
2. Sandy Koufax (bart, ham)
Region IV
1. Tom Seaver (Jug, Foli)
4. Greg Maddux (ham, dirt, whisky, chi)
3. Randy Johnson (happy, tm, Benne)
2. Roger Clemens (Bart)
Regional Finals
Region I
1. Christy Mathewson (Ham, scooterpie, dirt)
2. Cy Young
Region II
1. Walter Johnson (dirt, Bart, scooterpie)
2. Lefty Grove (ME)
Region III
1. Warren Spahn (happy, scooterpie, bart)
3. Bob Gibson (dirt)
Region IV
4. Greg Maddux (dirt, ham, happy, ME)
3. Randy Johnson (bart)
The Final 4
1. Christy Mathewson
1. Walter Johnson (bart, dirt, happy)
1. Warren Spahn (bart)
4. Greg Maddux (Ham, scooterpie, Foli)
FINALS
1. Walter Johnson (bart, tm, jug, ham)
4. Greg Maddux
[Edited on 2-2-2009 by barterer2002]
[Edited on 2-2-2009 by barterer2002]
Return of the brackets-SP edition-Walter Johnson wins
January 23, 2009 at 10:32PM View BBCode
Alright you know how this works. You may vote for 1 player per region per day and you may only vote for a player once per round so it will take 3 different people voting for a player to advance him. If you think that someone does not belong in the group of 64 you need to tell me who should be here instead. I will consider allowing write in campaigns if they don't get stupid.bold players have advanced and votes for either in that pairing will not be counted
Here are the brackets
Region I. 1871-1920
1. Christy Mathewson (Benne, Scooterpie, Bart)
9. Jack Chesbro (Ham)
5. Three Finger Brown (chi925a, Brown, happy)
4. John Clarkson (jchell, chi925)
3. Kid Nichols (Benne, foli, jchell)
6. Al Spalding (Bart, Jug, ME)
7. Ed Walsh (ME, scooterpie, Dirt)
2. Cy Young (Jughead, Benne, Yar, happy)
Region II 1900-1945
1. Walter Johnson (happy, scooterpie, Bart)
8. Burleigh Grimes (Benne, bart, foli)
5. Dizzy Dean (Jughead, happy, Dirt)
4. Eddie Plank (Jchell, Jug, scooterpie)
3. Grover Cleveland "Pete" Alexander (Bart, scooterpie, Benne, chi925, happy)
6. Carl Hubbell (Dirt, Jchell, Yar, Foli)
7. Dazzy Vance (Ham, foli, Bart)
2. Lefty Grove (Benne, chi925a, happy)
Region III 1935-1975
1. Warren Spahn (happy, Dirt, Bart)
9. Don Drysdale (jchell, Yar, dirt)
5. Juan Marichal (jughead, happy, Benne, Fooli, Chi915)
4. Robin Roberts (Bart, jchell, happy
3. Bob Gibson (chi925a, scooterpie, foli)
6. Bob Feller (Benne, bart, Jug)
7. Early Wynn (scooterpie, jchell, bart)
2. Sandy Koufax (Ham, Bart, scooterpie)
Region IV 1965-2008
1. Tom Seaver (Bart, foli, jchell)
8. Gaylord Perry (ME, chi925a, happy)
5. Steve Carlton (Dirt, Bart, Benne)
4. Greg Maddux (Ham, chi925a, dirt)
3. Randy Johnson (Benne, happy, jchell, bart)
6. Pedro Martinez (happy, Yar, ME)
7. Jim Palmer (scooterpie, Foli, happy)
2. Roger Clemens (bart, scooterpie, Benne)
ROUND 2
Region I
1. Christy Mathewson (Jug, Scooterpie, Bart)
5. Three Finger Brown (happy, jchell, scooterpie)
6. Al Spalding (bart, happy, scooterpie)
2. Cy Young (Benne, dirt, jchell)
Region II
1. Walter Johnson (happy, bart, scooterpie)
5. Dizzy Dean (happy, Bart, Foli)
3. Grover Cleveland Alexander (ham, bart, dirt)
2. Lefty Grove (jug, scooterpie, Benne)
Region III
1. Warren Spahn (bart, happy, scooterpie)
5. Juan Marichal (scooterpie, jchell, Foli)
3. Bob Gibson (scooterpie, jug, Ham)
2. Sandy Koufax (ham, Benne, bart)
Region IV
1. Tom Seaver (bart, scooterpie. jchell)
4. Greg Maddux (Ham, jchell, happy)
3. Randy Johnson (jchell, Benne, bart)
2. Roger Clemens (Jug, dirt, bart)
The Sweet 16
Region I
1. Christy Mathewson (dirt, scooterpie, Jug)
2. Cy Young (scooterpie, dirt, bart)
Region II
1. Walter Johnson (tm, scooterpie, dirt)
2. Lefty Grove (happy, bart, tm)
Region III
1. Warren Spahn (Benne, spahn, bart)
3. Bob Gibson (jug, scooterpie, tm)
Region IV
4. Greg Maddux (ham, dirt, whisky, chi)
3. Randy Johnson (happy, tm, Benne)
Regional Finals
Region I
1. Christy Mathewson (Ham, scooterpie, dirt)
Region II
1. Walter Johnson (dirt, Bart, scooterpie)
Region III
1. Warren Spahn (happy, scooterpie, bart)
Region IV
4. Greg Maddux (dirt, ham, happy, ME)
The Final 4
1. Walter Johnson (bart, dirt, happy)
4. Greg Maddux (Ham, scooterpie, Foli)
FINALS
1. Walter Johnson (bart, tm, jug, ham)
[Edited on 2-2-2009 by barterer2002]
[Edited on 2-2-2009 by barterer2002]
dirtdevil
January 23, 2009 at 10:56PM View BBCode
i'll take carlton, before someone decides that nolan ryan is more than a .500 pitcher.
barterer2002
Carlton, Roberts, Alexander and Spalding
January 23, 2009 at 11:01PM View BBCode
Guys you can vote for one in each bracket. I'm going to vote forCarlton, Roberts, Alexander and Spalding
Hamilton2
Jack Chesbro
Dazzy Vance
Sandy Koufax
Greg Maddux
Also, Old Hoss Radburne is listed twice ...
January 24, 2009 at 12:05AM View BBCode
I'll take:Jack Chesbro
Dazzy Vance
Sandy Koufax
Greg Maddux
Also, Old Hoss Radburne is listed twice ...
Benne
Lefty Grove
Bob Feller
Randy Johnson
January 24, 2009 at 03:45AM View BBCode
Christy MathewsonLefty Grove
Bob Feller
Randy Johnson
happy
January 24, 2009 at 05:24AM View BBCode
im confused, why did bart vote for the same guy as dirtdevil?
Benne
January 24, 2009 at 05:52AM View BBCode
Originally posted by happy
im confused, why did bart vote for the same guy as dirtdevil?
You may vote for 1 player per region per day and you may only vote for a player once per round so it will take 3 different people voting for a player to advance him.
happy
??
I guess he means "has yet to be selected 3 times"?
And he said you vote once per day, can you vote for the same guy twice, or do you vote for a different matchup?
(I'm all of a sudden paranoid that im going to screw up. And I want to vote for pedro again!)
January 24, 2009 at 07:35AM View BBCode
Originally posted by barterer2002
Select a matchup that someone else has yet to select.
??
I guess he means "has yet to be selected 3 times"?
And he said you vote once per day, can you vote for the same guy twice, or do you vote for a different matchup?
(I'm all of a sudden paranoid that im going to screw up. And I want to vote for pedro again!)
ScooterPie
I'll take Matty over Welch, Johnson over Ruffing, Gibson over Bunning, and Glavine over Perry.
I'll also mention that Ciocotti is spelled "Cicotte."
scooter
January 24, 2009 at 12:04PM View BBCode
Don't worry, happy, I'm sure I'll screw it up worse than you.I'll take Matty over Welch, Johnson over Ruffing, Gibson over Bunning, and Glavine over Perry.
I'll also mention that Ciocotti is spelled "Cicotte."
scooter
barterer2002
I get Mathewson, Johnson, Koufax, Seaver
January 24, 2009 at 01:55PM View BBCode
OK Day 2, new votes allowed (you can't vote for a player you voted for yesterdayI get Mathewson, Johnson, Koufax, Seaver
ScooterPie
Gimme Rube Waddell, Pete Alexander, Sandy Koufax, and Jim Palmer.
January 24, 2009 at 03:00PM View BBCode
Do I get to vote again already?Gimme Rube Waddell, Pete Alexander, Sandy Koufax, and Jim Palmer.
barterer2002
January 24, 2009 at 03:29PM View BBCode
Sorry scooter, you already voted this morning, you have to wait til tomorrow, those who voted last night can vote again.
dirtdevil
January 24, 2009 at 04:26PM View BBCode
i'll go with brown, hubbell, spahn, and i'll close out maddux.
jchelland
Region 2 - Hubbell
Region 3 - Drysdale
Region 4 - Tommy John
This is a cool idea Bart. I like it.
[Edited on 1-24-2009 by jchelland]
January 24, 2009 at 04:35PM View BBCode
Region 1 - ClarksonRegion 2 - Hubbell
Region 3 - Drysdale
Region 4 - Tommy John
This is a cool idea Bart. I like it.
[Edited on 1-24-2009 by jchelland]
jchelland
[Edited on 1-24-2009 by jchelland]
January 24, 2009 at 05:21PM View BBCode
Wait Bart I am confused - I voted for Tommy John, but now I notice that he is already Bold over Clemens. Did he get a free "not on the juice" pass or something?[Edited on 1-24-2009 by jchelland]
bobcat73
Region I. 1871-1920
1. Christy Mathewson (Benne, Scooterpie, Bart)
8. Joe McGinnity
12. Tim Keefe
4. John Clarkson (jchell)
14. Rube Marquard
11. Pud Galvin
7. Ed Walsh
2. Cy Young (Jughead)
Region II 1900-1945
1. Walter Johnson (happy, scooterpie, Bart)
8. Burleigh Grimes (Benne)
5. Dizzy Dean (Jughead)
13. Wes Ferrell
3. Grover Cleveland "Pete" Alexander (Bart)
6. Carl Hubbell (Dirt, Jchell)
7. Dazzy Vance (Ham, foli)
2. Lefty Grove (Benne, chi925a)
Region III 1935-1975
1. Warren Spahn (happy, Dirt)
9. Don Drysdale (jchell)
12. Don Newcombe
4. Robin Roberts (Bart)
3. Bob Gibson (chi925a, scooterpie, foli)
11. Lefty Gomez
7. Early Wynn
2. Sandy Koufax (Ham, Bart)
Region IV 1965-2008
1. Tom Seaver (Bart, foli)
8. Gaylord Perry
12. Nolan Ryan
4. Greg Maddux (Ham, chi925a, dirt)
3. Randy Johnson (Benne)
11. Phil Niekro
10. Fergie Jenkins
15. Tommy John (jchell)
January 24, 2009 at 11:22PM View BBCode
Here are the bracketsRegion I. 1871-1920
1. Christy Mathewson (Benne, Scooterpie, Bart)
8. Joe McGinnity
12. Tim Keefe
4. John Clarkson (jchell)
14. Rube Marquard
11. Pud Galvin
7. Ed Walsh
2. Cy Young (Jughead)
Region II 1900-1945
1. Walter Johnson (happy, scooterpie, Bart)
8. Burleigh Grimes (Benne)
5. Dizzy Dean (Jughead)
13. Wes Ferrell
3. Grover Cleveland "Pete" Alexander (Bart)
6. Carl Hubbell (Dirt, Jchell)
7. Dazzy Vance (Ham, foli)
2. Lefty Grove (Benne, chi925a)
Region III 1935-1975
1. Warren Spahn (happy, Dirt)
9. Don Drysdale (jchell)
12. Don Newcombe
4. Robin Roberts (Bart)
3. Bob Gibson (chi925a, scooterpie, foli)
11. Lefty Gomez
7. Early Wynn
2. Sandy Koufax (Ham, Bart)
Region IV 1965-2008
1. Tom Seaver (Bart, foli)
8. Gaylord Perry
12. Nolan Ryan
4. Greg Maddux (Ham, chi925a, dirt)
3. Randy Johnson (Benne)
11. Phil Niekro
10. Fergie Jenkins
15. Tommy John (jchell)
happy
lefty grove
Juan Marichal
Randy Johnson
Also, no Addie Joss? :P
January 25, 2009 at 03:09AM View BBCode
three finger brownlefty grove
Juan Marichal
Randy Johnson
Also, no Addie Joss? :P
barterer2002
If I were putting him in I'd probably knock Warneke out which would move Ruffing over to Region 3 still as the 16 seed. I'd also move Brown over to Region II as the 5 seed with Dean and everyone else dropping down a slot. Joss would probably fall about 13 with Waddell and everyone else up to Walsh moving up a slot.
Not going to do it at this point but that's where I'd be.
January 25, 2009 at 03:36AM View BBCode
Yeah Joss should probably go in there. I went through with a bunch of pitchers that I knew would be in and excluded Joss. Ended up with about 40 or so and should have added Joss back in during the next 24 but missed him.If I were putting him in I'd probably knock Warneke out which would move Ruffing over to Region 3 still as the 16 seed. I'd also move Brown over to Region II as the 5 seed with Dean and everyone else dropping down a slot. Joss would probably fall about 13 with Waddell and everyone else up to Walsh moving up a slot.
Not going to do it at this point but that's where I'd be.